COTTAGE BAKERY COMING SOON TO GEORGIA!

The
New York
Italian
Bake Shop

The New York Italian Bake ShopThe New York Italian Bake ShopThe New York Italian Bake Shop

The
New York
Italian
Bake Shop

The New York Italian Bake ShopThe New York Italian Bake ShopThe New York Italian Bake Shop
  • WELCOME
  • CATERING & WHOLESALE
  • THE ITALIAN COOKIE JAR
  • NEW YORK FAVORITES
  • BLOG
  • ABOUT THE BAKE SHOP
  • CONTACT US
  • More
    • WELCOME
    • CATERING & WHOLESALE
    • THE ITALIAN COOKIE JAR
    • NEW YORK FAVORITES
    • BLOG
    • ABOUT THE BAKE SHOP
    • CONTACT US
Get in Touch
  • WELCOME
  • CATERING & WHOLESALE
  • THE ITALIAN COOKIE JAR
  • NEW YORK FAVORITES
  • BLOG
  • ABOUT THE BAKE SHOP
  • CONTACT US
Get in Touch

THE ITALIAN COOKIE JAR

Sugar-coated peach-shaped pastries with green leaves.

Italian Cookies

Cherry Rosette

Cherry Rosette choc dip

Sprinkle/Choc Chip/Fudge star

Thumbprint raspberry/apricot/choc dot

Italian Knot

Snow Ball

Regina Sesa

Savoiardi

Amaretti Cherry

Rainbow Cookie

Cuccidati


Sandwich Cookies:

Long Vanilla/Chocolate/Almond

(fillings: raspberry, apricot, orange/pineapple, fudge)

Red Velvet Rosette

Italian Leaf

Florentine

Pesche Dolci

filling:  Jam/Nutella

PignoliAlmond

*ask about our Viral Rainbow Pignoli Cookie!

Layered red, white, and blue cake squares with sprinkles.

Custom Rainbow Cookie Gift Box

custom chocolate message can be added when ordering

Tri-colored layered cake squares on a decorative plate with sprinkles.

Rainbow Cookie Tower gift wrapped

Rainbow cookies beautifully gift wrapped in cello and bow. Cookie colors can be customized.

Golden cookies topped with red cherry preserves on parchment paper.

Assorted Italian Butter Cookie Tray Gift Wrapped

Includes assorted butter cookies beautifully gift wrapped in cello and bow.  A perfect gift for any occasion!  


Assorted Italian cookie tray is available during the holiday season only.

Individual Italian Cookie Favors

A sweet Italian tradition for your special day!

Looking for a favor guests will actually enjoy?

Gift them handcrafted Italian cookie favors made with love.  Custom ribbons are available.

All items are made to order and require two day notice. A one to two month notice for The Wedding Cookie Table is appreciated.

Copyright © 2024 The NY Italian Bake Shop - All Rights Reserved.

  • WELCOME
  • THE ITALIAN COOKIE JAR
  • NEW YORK FAVORITES
  • BLOG
  • ABOUT THE BAKE SHOP
  • CONTACT US

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept