ABOUT THE BAKE SHOP

The NY Italian Bake Shop is a New York style Italian-American Cottage Bakery.  We specialize in bringing the flavors of traditional old school New York Italian bakeries to your table, crafted with tradition, heart, and time-honored family recipes.

I was born in Brooklyn, NY and raised on Long Island, where authentic Italian bake shops seemed to be on every corner. Being Italian American meant traditions, family gatherings, and celebrating every birthday and holiday together. No celebration was complete without a visit to our neighborhood Italian bakery to pick out cakes and pastries to make the moment special.

Some of my fondest memories are standing in awe of bakery shelves during the holidays—filled with beautifully gift-wrapped cookie trays that felt truly magical. Cannoli cake holds a special place in my heart, as it was my dad’s favorite, and it continues to inspire the desserts I create today.

My love for cooking and baking started early—and it’s no surprise, because I learned from the best. I was always recreating popular New York and Italian-inspired desserts, especially during the holidays, and sharing them with family and friends. My favorite dessert to bake are rainbow cookies, and my recipes are inspired by some of the most well-known and beloved bakeries in New York.  After moving to the Lone Star State, I realized how much I missed sharing my Italian heritage, my baking, and the authentic flavors of New York Italian bakeries. That longing became the mission behind The NY Italian Texan Bake Shop.  To bring authentic New York Italian bakery flavor to you with the highest possible quality, care, and attention to detail.  We are excited for our new location in Georgia, and to offer our delicious baked goods to the local businesses and public!

We specialize in traditional Italian cookies, and classic rainbow cookies, all fresh, handmade, and made from scratch. Our baked goods are made to order, ensuring peak freshness and flavor. Preorders can be placed by email.

From our homemade candied fruit and almond paste, every item reflects old-world Italian baking techniques. We proudly offer catering to the public for holidays, birthdays, weddings, special events, including custom Italian & American Wedding Cookie Tables, and Dessert Tables, each designed to feel personal, nostalgic, and unforgettable.  Wholesale orders for local businesses are welcome!

The NY Italian Bake Shop will be operating as a Georgia Cottage Bakery after getting settled in a new home in GA.  Joanna is food manager certified with extensive commercial kitchen experience.  Please note that our home kitchen is not nut-free, wheat-free, milk-free, or soy-free.  Every order is made with intention, tradition, and love.

The NY Italian Bake Shop, by Joanna Di Sclafani.

Where every bite tastes like home!

While I like to keep my menu traditional, I also stay inspired by new trends found in the best New York bake shops and beyond.  Ask me about my viral rainbow cookie menu!

My signature  rainbow cookies are made with fresh and scratch made almond paste! Check out our full menu of  rainbow cookie themed items!

Custom Rainbow Cookies

Viral Rainbow Pignoli Cookies

Rainbow Cookie crumb cake

Rainbow Cookie doughnuts

Rainbow Cookie cupcakes

Rainbow Cookie rugelach